RTI, transparency, N-Deal and some random thoughts - Instablogs
RTI, transparency, N-Deal and some random thoughts
Jitaditya , Ahmedabad: Jul 5 2008
Made Popular Jul 6 2008
India :

RTI, transparency, N-Deal and some random thoughts

When the Right to Information Act (RTI) was enacted some time ago, it created an unprecedented wave of optimism and activity among the general populace. We heard a lot of stories where people exercised their rights and made the corrupt and the vicious bite the dust. Now with time, the enthusiasm has waned and I think the loopholes have been discovered and being used to avoid the same.

Certain informations related to national security were never covered in this act for justifiable reasons. But as the debate surrounding the N-Deal rages on, it brings about certain questions.

• Lots of time has been spent by the media and the experts discussing the pros and cons of the deal. But does anyone know the complete picture?
• The government keeps saying it is in national interest. So why can’t they stand up and declare a concrete assurance?
• Finally why can’t they make the relevant information public? It is an issue of national security. But for the same reason the public has to know the implications of it. Where is the transparency in the process?

Due to such reluctance in taking the people into faith, other parties have got the opportunity to create a pseudo-populist melodrama. The left parties are trying to create a sensation by posing as the greatest patriots. But when we see them warning the Samajwadi Party saying that supporting the N Deal would cost Muslim votes, we know that it is no patriotism and only petty votebank politics. Perhaps Mulayam Singh Yadav has done a good thing (one of the rare good things for him) by asking the PM to clear the doubts in public. But still we have not seen any positive development. Hope they realize it very soon and clear the doubt in our minds. After all this how they can save the government!

Image

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Prasad
Howrah, India
The nuclear deal is just not in the national interest primarily because of the following reasons:

a) The Nuclear Suppliers Group members are under no obligation to sell nuclear fuel to India. They can deny India if they have different national policies to that of the US. E.g. Australia recently denied selling uranium to India because they want India to sign the NPT first. This might mean that the nuclear power stations that India might build with the important technology may be rendered non-functional useless units due to unavailability of fuel.

b) Why should we sign something that guarantees an external agency like IAEA to put checks and inspect on the civilian reactors for misuse 'in perpetuity'. It leaves no scope for India to walk out of the deal.

c) Why should India jump the gun and sign the dotted lines when it doesn't know yet what the final draft would be and what the language of the agreement would look like. We must not forget that it is yet to be passed in the American Congress.
1 Stars
Ayushi
Calicut, India
The Samaajwadi Party is now singing a predictable tune. It is the endorsement of former president Abdul Kalam. It is so shameful that his statement is used in this fashion. What about his other visions on farming, education and empowerment of people at the grassroots level especially women?
1 Stars
Lalit
Kanpur, India
Amar Singh on July 5, 2008 at a press conference in Delhi:

Na Khata Na Bahi, Kalam Sahab Jo Kahey Wahi Sahi


Eerily similar to the Congress party's famous line on Sitaram Kesri who was the treasurer of the party and afectionately called chacha or uncle.

Na Khata Na Bahi, Chacha Jo Kahey Wahi Sahi
1 Stars
Julie
New Delhi, India
The Right To Information Act was perhaps the most positive thing happened since Independence. There might be many obstacles still in getting all the information that you might want to have but a lot of things are happening and that includes getting things sped up at the bureaucracy levels.
1 Stars
Swati
Amritsar, India
The government seems to be keeping something regarding the deal from the general public. It doesn't take an RTI to get the draft of the deal that the Manmohan Singh government is so hell-bent on signing. Everyone can have it. There should be a national debate on this.
1 Stars
Ketul
Jamshedpur, India
Is the nuclear deal so important that the government is risking itself from being defeated at the floor of the house? I thought that the price rise and inflation are the main worries for the government and it should be concentrating on it than a fishy deal.
1 Stars
Brajesh
Banglore, India
I was just watching the interview of AB Bardhan with Arnab Goswami in Times Now. I found it quite remarkable that the Left has withdrawn support from the government because of the nuclear deal and not because of the rising inflation. This is a tactical blunder by the Left. But I think reading all the stuff from experts like Brahma Chellaney that the nuclear deal may not be in the best interests of the country.
1 Stars
@all
Thanks for the comments guys...

I do believe we have that we have a case of mistaken priorities. The N deal might be important from an energy security point of view. But for the same reason all the aspects has to be clarified. All the parties are playing their cards in this issue as they are getting a lot of media attention.
1 Stars
Nuclear energy is not an immediate viable option either. For a hugely populated country like ours there is no scientific evidence that n-energy will solve all energy related the problems. N-energy will bring whole lot of problems with it...one of it being that of nuclear waste...but no harm in going with deal in the scientific and research interests of the country.
About our political drama...neither Left has been able to convince others as to why they are opposing the deal...it is just using the issue to blackmail UPA for long time. Whereas inflation is more urgent issue...and it is not using that either...
1 Stars
That’s exactly where we are faltering. Nukes are really powerful but they can be risky and if something happens the aftermath continues for decades.

We get to hear occasional talks about other sources like solar, wind, geothermal energy etc. But I don’t know why such things are not scaled up!
1 Stars
We all had the same questions in our minds. Thanks for putting them down, Jitaditya.

Nice piece, indeed.
1 Stars
Thanx a lot...
Add your Comment